OpenAI recently revealed a study highlighting that the majority of users use the chatbot for tasks outside of the office for things such as meal planning, information support and advice. As someone who has tested all the major chatbots including the best alternatives to ChatGPT, I have to agree that AI is very useful for helping me stay organized and productive outside of the office.
That’s why I just had to know how ChatGPT compares to Claude, one of its biggest competitors, when it comes to reasoning and writing. Here’s what happened when I put the two highly-capable chatbots through a series of personal productivity tests.
1. Time blocking and scheduling
Prompt: “I work from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., but I need to fit in a 30-minute workout, two 15-minute breaks, and two hours of deep-focus writing. Can you design a realistic daily schedule for me? Workout needs to be before 9 a.m. with time to shower.”
ChatGPT detailed my entire day, starting at 7:30. It took into account every aspect including lunch and ways to unwind after work. This felt like too much, almost confining me to stay on task.
Claude gave me an earlier start, which should automatically disqualify it (kidding) and created a reasonable schedule that would be easy for me to follow.
Winner: Claude wins for a thoughtful, but less restricting schedule.
2. Task prioritization
Prompt: “Here’s a to-do list: write a blog post, prepare dinner, answer 30 unread emails, fold laundry, and schedule a dentist appointment. I only have 3 hours tonight. Which order should I tackle these in for maximum productivity, and why?”
ChatGPT suggested I prepare dinner first. This makes sense because it takes care of my family so they aren’t hungry while I’m trying to do other tasks.
Claude created a schedule that might work for me if I was living on my own and didn’t have a family to take care of, but based on this schedule, they’d be eating dinner way too late.
Winner: ChatGPT wins for pure practicality and family-first thinking.
3. Summarization and action items
Prompt: “Summarize this text into 3 key takeaways and 3 action steps:
‘The team meeting discussed Q3 targets, with emphasis on increasing brand awareness through social media campaigns. Budget cuts mean we’ll have to scale back on paid ads, but influencer partnerships are being explored. A new intern will help with content scheduling.’”
ChatGPT approached the meeting notes with precision and brevity with the bare minimum output.
Claude highlighted the takeaways in bold, adding details and then offering action steps, also bolding the most important text so it was easier to read at a glance.
Winner: Claude wins for drafting a summary that literally highlights the action items so they are easy to read and digestible.
4. Decision-making aid
Prompt: “I have an hour free tonight. Should I spend it cleaning the kitchen, working out, or reading a book? Please give me pros and cons for each option, then suggest the best choice.”
ChatGPT delivered a detail list of the pros and cons of each option and then presented the “best choice” by leaving me with the decision based on how I was personally feeling.
Claude also highlighted the pros and cons of each option, but didn’t make me decide; it told me to workout and why.
Winner: Claude wins for the more decisive and confident answer that better helped me decide how to spend my free time.
5. Brainstorming
Prompt: “I want to get better at saving time in the kitchen. Can you brainstorm 10 practical time-saving cooking hacks that don’t sacrifice meal quality?”
ChatGPT offered several useful tips and included why they would help me save time. It also suggested setting timers for short bursts of work so I wouldn’t get lost in distractions, practical advice that I could easily apply.
Claude created a list with similar tips, but went a step further in how it framed them. The chatbot better elaborated on not only why they would help but how.
Winner: Claude wins here for being the better productivity and time-saving assistant in this case.
6. Email drafting
Prompt: “Write a professional but friendly email to my boss requesting Friday off for a family event. Keep it under 100 words and make sure it sounds polite and reasonable.”
ChatGPT drafted a concise note that could double as either an email or a Slack message. It was clear, efficient and respectful of my boss’ time and attention.
Claude produced a more thoughtful message. It not only emphasized why I deserved the time off but also included a brief summary of how I had managed my workload to make the request easier to approve.
Winner: Claude wins for striking the right balance between professionalism and persuasion.
7. Weekly planning
Prompt: “Help me plan my week. I need to balance work, family time, exercise, and personal reading. Suggest a balanced 7-day plan with daily highlights.”
ChatGPT generated a straightforward plan for my week and included a balanced mix of personal, professional and family time.
Claude developed a plan with a theme for each day of the week. I found this to be a nice touch to help me remember the plan while staying focused.
Winner: Claude wins for a more thoughtful and memorable schedule.
Final thoughts
After putting both chatbots through seven personal productivity tests, the winner is clear. Claude consistently delivered the best results while also explaining the reasoning behind each response, making each one more actionable. ChatGPT shines when it comes to quick, practical solutions that respect time, often cutting straight to the point, proving its worth when time is of the essence.
I use both chatbots interchangeably for personal productivity solutions, but with the prompts for this test, it’s evident that Claude takes the crown as the stronger assistant (for now). There’s no doubt that ChatGPT is still an excellent tool for fast, no-frills answers, but Claude’s balance of clarity, detail and decisiveness makes it the better choice for anyone looking to save time and stay organized in a meaningful way.
Follow Tom’s Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!
More from Tom’s Guide
Back to Laptops
